Since the 2017–18 season, Monmouth and William & Mary have met 4 times and split them evenly at 2–2.
Most recently Monmouth won 81–70 on January 8, 2026.
Right now Monmouth is 0–0 and William & Mary is 0–0, with William & Mary at 213 days since a win against Monmouth's 211.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thu, Jan 8 2026 | Monmouth home | Monmouth | 81–70 |
| Sat, Jan 25 2025 | William & Mary home | William & Mary | 78–73 |
| Thu, Feb 8 2024 | Monmouth home | Monmouth | 68–64 |
| Sat, Feb 25 2023 | William & Mary home | William & Mary | 74–62 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Monmouth Hawks and William & Mary Tribe.
Monmouth vs Campbell, Monmouth vs Charleston, Monmouth vs Drexel, Monmouth vs Elon, Monmouth vs Hampton, Monmouth vs Hofstra, Monmouth vs North Carolina A&T, Monmouth vs Northeastern, Monmouth vs Stony Brook, Monmouth vs Towson, Monmouth vs UNC Wilmington.
William & Mary vs Campbell, William & Mary vs Charleston, William & Mary vs Drexel, William & Mary vs Elon, William & Mary vs Hampton, William & Mary vs Hofstra, William & Mary vs North Carolina A&T, William & Mary vs Northeastern, William & Mary vs Stony Brook, William & Mary vs Towson, William & Mary vs UNC Wilmington.