Since the 2017–18 season, Elon and Monmouth have met 5 times, and Monmouth has the better of it at 3–2.
Most recently Monmouth won 73–57 on February 28, 2026.
Right now Elon is 0–0 and Monmouth is 0–0, with Elon at 234 days since a win against Monmouth's 211.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, Feb 28 2026 | Monmouth home | Monmouth | 73–57 |
| Thu, Feb 27 2025 | Monmouth home | Monmouth | 79–76 |
| Thu, Jan 23 2025 | Elon home | Elon | 83–71 |
| Sat, Mar 2 2024 | Elon home | Monmouth | 85–70 |
| Sat, Feb 18 2023 | Monmouth home | Elon | 75–68 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Elon Phoenix and Monmouth Hawks.
Elon vs Campbell, Elon vs Charleston, Elon vs Drexel, Elon vs Hampton, Elon vs Hofstra, Elon vs North Carolina A&T, Elon vs Northeastern, Elon vs Stony Brook, Elon vs Towson, Elon vs UNC Wilmington, Elon vs William & Mary.
Monmouth vs Campbell, Monmouth vs Charleston, Monmouth vs Drexel, Monmouth vs Hampton, Monmouth vs Hofstra, Monmouth vs North Carolina A&T, Monmouth vs Northeastern, Monmouth vs Stony Brook, Monmouth vs Towson, Monmouth vs UNC Wilmington, Monmouth vs William & Mary.