Since the 2017–18 season, Elon and William & Mary have met 21 times, and William & Mary has the better of it at 12–9.
Most recently William & Mary won 72–62 on March 7, 2026.
Right now Elon is 0–0 and William & Mary is 0–0, with Elon at 234 days since a win against William & Mary's 213.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, Mar 7 2026 | Neutral site | William & Mary | 72–62 |
| Sat, Feb 14 2026 | William & Mary home | Elon | 81–78 |
| Thu, Jan 29 2026 | Elon home | Elon | 79–76 |
| Sat, Feb 22 2025 | Elon home | William & Mary | 79–70 |
| Thu, Jan 9 2025 | William & Mary home | William & Mary | 78–65 |
| Thu, Feb 29 2024 | Elon home | Elon | 76–71 |
| Thu, Jan 4 2024 | William & Mary home | William & Mary | 77–70 |
| Sat, Mar 4 2023 | Neutral site | William & Mary | 73–51 |
| Thu, Feb 23 2023 | William & Mary home | William & Mary | 73–60 |
| Sat, Feb 11 2023 | Elon home | Elon | 66–55 |
| Sat, Jan 29 2022 | William & Mary home | William & Mary | 65–61 |
| Thu, Jan 27 2022 | Elon home | Elon | 61–54 |
| Mon, Feb 22 2021 | Elon home | Elon | 73–54 |
| Sat, Feb 20 2021 | William & Mary home | Elon | 75–54 |
| Sun, Mar 8 2020 | Neutral site | Elon | 68–63 |
| Sat, Feb 29 2020 | William & Mary home | William & Mary | 86–79 |
| Mon, Dec 30 2019 | Elon home | William & Mary | 74–73 |
| Sat, Feb 16 2019 | Elon home | William & Mary | 84–74 |
| Sat, Jan 19 2019 | William & Mary home | Elon | 76–71 |
| Thu, Feb 1 2018 | William & Mary home | William & Mary | 99–92 |
| Sat, Jan 20 2018 | Elon home | William & Mary | 80–73 |
Full schedules and drought counters: Elon Phoenix and William & Mary Tribe.
Elon vs Campbell, Elon vs Charleston, Elon vs Drexel, Elon vs Hampton, Elon vs Hofstra, Elon vs Monmouth, Elon vs North Carolina A&T, Elon vs Northeastern, Elon vs Stony Brook, Elon vs Towson, Elon vs UNC Wilmington.
William & Mary vs Campbell, William & Mary vs Charleston, William & Mary vs Drexel, William & Mary vs Hampton, William & Mary vs Hofstra, William & Mary vs Monmouth, William & Mary vs North Carolina A&T, William & Mary vs Northeastern, William & Mary vs Stony Brook, William & Mary vs Towson, William & Mary vs UNC Wilmington.