Since 2017, App State and James Madison have met 4 times and split them evenly at 2–2.
Most recently James Madison won 58–10 on November 15, 2025.
Right now App State is 3–1 and James Madison is 5–0, with App State at 17 days since a win against James Madison's 3.
| Date | Site | Winner | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sat, Nov 15 2025 | James Madison home | James Madison | 58–10 |
| Sat, Nov 23 2024 | App State home | App State | 34–20 |
| Sat, Nov 18 2023 | James Madison home | App State | 26–23 |
| Sat, Sep 24 2022 | App State home | James Madison | 32–28 |
Full schedules and drought counters: App State Mountaineers and James Madison Dukes.
App State vs Coastal Carolina, App State vs Georgia Southern, App State vs Georgia State, App State vs Marshall, App State vs Old Dominion, App State vs Arkansas State, App State vs Louisiana, App State vs Louisiana Tech, App State vs South Alabama, App State vs Southern Miss, App State vs Troy, App State vs UL Monroe.
James Madison vs Coastal Carolina, James Madison vs Georgia Southern, James Madison vs Georgia State, James Madison vs Marshall, James Madison vs Old Dominion, James Madison vs Arkansas State, James Madison vs Louisiana, James Madison vs Louisiana Tech, James Madison vs South Alabama, James Madison vs Southern Miss, James Madison vs Troy, James Madison vs UL Monroe.